Lancashire Butter Pie and the Pleasure of a Meatless Friday

Lancashire Butter Pie and the Pleasure of a Meatless Friday

A Lancashire butter pie sounds like the sort of thing you might order on a dare. The name promises butter, and the pie is admirably honest about how much it intends to use. Inside the golden shortcrust sit layers of sliced potato and softened onion, glossy with melted butter and well seasoned with pepper. Cut a wedge and the layers slump a little onto the plate. This is generally the point at which everyone stops asking what else is in it.

In Preston, the pie owes its place at the table to the city’s Catholic tradition of abstaining from meat on Fridays. Hence its other names, Friday pie and Catholic pie. The custom explains how a meatless pie made from ordinary ingredients became a local staple. Over time, it found a place beyond the Friday table. You can even have one at half-time at a Preston North End match, when comfort may be more urgently required.

The pie also turns up in Chorley, and it works just as well as an individual bakery pie. At home, however, a larger pie gives you room to build alternating layers of potato and onion. Some recipes use lard in the pastry for a flaky crust. Others use vegetable fat alongside butter, which keeps the pie vegetarian. You can add grated Lancashire cheese if you fancy it, though then you’re edging into cheese and onion pie territory. The three-ingredient filling has survived perfectly well without the help.

What makes it special is the way the butter settles between the potato slices. The edges soften, the centres hold their shape and the onion turns sweet enough to take a generous grind of pepper. Pickled red cabbage is a natural partner because its sharpness cuts through the buttery filling. Alternatively, serve it with mushy peas and brown sauce for a chippy-style supper. A dry cider works well with the sweet onion, while a pint of bitter suits the pastry. For a bakery wedge eaten warm from the paper bag, a mug of strong tea will do nicely.

Potatoes bring potassium and some fibre to the plate. Still, between the buttery filling and the pastry, this is a rich pie with plenty of saturated fat. A modest wedge with peas or steamed greens makes a satisfying supper and leaves enough pie for tomorrow. The recipe below contains wheat, milk and egg.

Lancashire butter pie recipe

This makes one 23cm pie and serves six. Allow about 35 minutes for preparation, 30 minutes to chill the pastry and 40–45 minutes to bake.

For the pastry, use 325g plain flour, ½ teaspoon fine salt, 160g cold unsalted butter, diced, and 5–7 tablespoons ice-cold water. For the filling, use 850g Maris Piper potatoes, two large onions, 110g unsalted butter, salt and plenty of freshly ground black pepper. Beat one egg for glazing.

Rub the pastry butter into the flour and salt until the mixture resembles coarse breadcrumbs. Then add the water a tablespoon at a time, using just enough to bring the dough together. Divide it into two discs, one roughly twice the size of the other. Wrap and refrigerate both for 30 minutes.

Meanwhile, peel the potatoes and slice them about 5mm thick. Simmer them in salted water for 5–7 minutes, until the edges soften but the slices still hold together. Drain well and spread them on a tray to cool. Thinly slice the onions and cook them gently in 40g of the filling butter for 12–15 minutes. Once they are soft and translucent, take them off the heat and leave them to cool.

Heat the oven to 200°C conventional, 180°C fan or gas mark 6, with a baking tray on the middle shelf. Roll out the larger disc and line a 23cm metal pie tin. Next, layer in the potatoes and onions, seasoning as you go and dotting the layers with the remaining butter.

Roll out the lid, brush the rim with beaten egg and press the edges together. Crimp the rim, cut a small slit in the centre and brush the lid with egg. Bake on the hot tray for 40–45 minutes, until the pastry is deep golden. Finally, let the pie stand for 10 minutes so the slices hold together when you serve them.

Post Comment